top of page

The Power of Authenticity: First Impressions in Interviews

Businesswoman and business man handshake

Creating a great first impression during a job interview is an art. In today's competitive job market, your first impression can significantly influence the outcome of your interview. Our recent poll offers valuable insights into what creates a memorable first impression. Furthermore, we've added practical suggestions based on these insights to aid job seekers in their journey.

The poll results were quite enlightening. 79% of respondents believe authenticity and a genuine smile make the most significant impact during an interview. A firm handshake was chosen by 11% of the participants, and 5% voted for the importance of dressing to impress.

Authenticity Above All

The fact that most respondents chose authenticity as their most important factor in making a great first impression aligns well with research in the field. A Harvard Business Review article highlights authenticity as one of the most critical elements in successful leadership. When candidates demonstrate their true selves in an interview, they communicate their genuine interest in the role and the organization. Furthermore, it shows they are comfortable with their skills and experiences and are ready to contribute to the team.

Practical Tip: Enhance your authenticity by building self-awareness. Understand your strengths, weaknesses, values, and passions. Be honest and consistent about your skills and experiences.

The Magic of a Genuine Smile

A genuine smile not only showcases authenticity but also demonstrates positivity and friendliness. Journal of Nonverbal Behavior published research that shows that smiling during a job interview can significantly influence the interviewer's perception of a candidate's competence and likability.

Practical Tip: Maintain a positive attitude, and remember to relax. Even practice your smile; it may sound odd, but it can make it feel more natural when the nerves kick in.

The Role of a Firm Handshake

While only 11% of respondents selected a firm handshake for making a great first impression, it is still a crucial aspect of interpersonal communication. The Journal of Applied Psychology study journal suggests a firm handshake can reflect confidence and professionalism.

Practical Tip: Your handshake should be firm but not crushing. It should last about two to three seconds and don't forget to maintain eye contact while shaking hands.


Dressing to Impress

Though dressing to impress might have received the least votes, it shouldn't be overlooked. According to a study by the Association for Psychological Science, professionally dressed individuals are perceived as more competent and trustworthy.

Practical Tip: Research the company culture and dress accordingly. Choose clothes you feel comfortable in and pay attention to details like neat hair, clean shoes, and minimal jewelry.

In conclusion, all these factors contribute to making a great first impression, with authenticity and a genuine smile leading the way. The poll results affirm the value of being true to oneself, demonstrating the power of authenticity, and highlighting the importance of human connection in the interview process.

Remember, creating a great first impression is a blend of these elements. Balance is key – your authentic self, positive demeanor, confident handshake, and professional attire all work together to leave a lasting impression.

Are you ready to elevate your career? Stay ahead of the curve. Follow us on LinkedIn or Subscribe to our newsletter. Get exclusive insights, industry trends, and expert advice right in your inbox. Don't miss the opportunity to lead your organization to new heights!

The resources used in this blog include:

1. Menity Research suite

2. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Pitch changes during attempted deception

3. Harvard Business Review (HBR). Reinventing the Job Interview

4. Journal of Applied Psychology. Exploring the Handshake in employment interviews

bottom of page